Which one is correct?

John P 10/08/2018. 13 answers
Education & Reference Words & Wordplay

1. I just saw a dog chasing a car and that car WAS his owner's car.

2. 1. I just saw a dog chasing a car and that car IS his owner's car.

13 Answers


John P 10/09/2018.

"I saw a dog chasing a car which belonged to its owner." That is what most British speakers of English might say. Both of your forms sound like "foreigner's English".

Note "its" because you do not know the sex of the dog. Most non-human creatures are referred to by "it" and "its" unless they are well-loved family pets or the sex is known for sure and is important to the conversation..


ML 10/08/2018.

One should know the grammar rule known as Consequence of Tenses. If you use Past in the first part , you have to use the same in the second..


JERRY 10/08/2018.

number one correct.


busterwasmycat 10/08/2018.

It is preferred to match tenses (the statements are true at the same time). The second clause could be used in the present tense if the statement is still true, of course. It would imply that the car was also the owner's car at the time of the chasing, or the statement would be "misleading". Something that might be used in a riddle to fool someone. the second statement could mean that the car was not the owner's car at the time of chasing even if the event "just" happened, but this would not be expected.


stef 10/08/2018.

Try paraphrasing. What I saw was a car chased by its owner's dog. Then,there's your solution to the question. Almost borders on heuristic reasoning!


Anonymous 10/08/2018.

Either would be OK - the fact that something has JUST happened implies that the ownership of the car would still be current.

If you said: I once saw a dog chasing a car and that car WAS his owner's car. Then it would firmly be in the past. (However the endless repetition of car would be something to avoid.)


charlatan 10/08/2018.

saw was


DR + Mrs Bears face 10/08/2018.

You saw the dog in the past and the car was his owners car at that time in the past so you may use was. If that car is still his owners car you may use is. Actually in the UK we would say neither. We would say "I just saw a dog chasing his owners car."


Elwin 10/08/2018.

This is one of those cases where the strictly correct grammar sounds wrong. 2 is correct (unless the owner sold the car in the mean time), but 1 would be the most common usage.


Kat 10/08/2018.

1 is the correct word.

It would be more natural to say

‘I just saw a dog chasing a car and it was his owner's car’

In the US, anyway. Fyi


hindsoft 10/10/2018.

1 is correct !


Robert 10/09/2018.

It depends upon the current ownership of the vehicle which you described as being chased by the dog. Was it sold by the dogs owner and currently owned by someone else. In that case it WAS the owner's car. If it is currently owned by the dog's owner it IS his owner's car. Check the registration and vehicle title in order to choose the sentence which will be more proper in your description of the events concerning vehicle ownership in the recent chase.


Stevo 10/08/2018.

number 2 because WAS refers to past tense in number 1, 2 is correct because just saw and IS refers to now or present.


HighResolutionMusic.com - Download Hi-Res Songs

1 Katy Perry

365 flac

Katy Perry. 2019. Writer: Zedd;Katy Perry;Caroline Ailin;Corey Sanders;Daniel Davidsen;Cutfather;Peter Wallevik.
2 5 Seconds Of Summer

Who Do You Love flac

5 Seconds Of Summer. 2019. Writer: Andrew Taggart;Talay Riley;Oak;Sean Douglas;Luke Hemmings;Calum Hood;Ashton Irwin;Michael Clifford;Trevorious;Zaire Koalo.
3 Brooks

Better When You're Gone flac

Brooks. 2019. Writer: David Guetta;Emma Lov Block;Ido Zmishlany;Jackson Foote;Jeremy Dussolliet;Brooks.
4 Ariana Grande

7 Rings flac

Ariana Grande. 2019. Writer: Ariana Grande;Richard Rodgers;TBHits;Njomza;Michael "Mikey" Foster;Kaydence;Tayla Parx;Scootie;Oscar Hammerstein II;Victoria Monét.
5 Bruno Mars

Please Me flac

Bruno Mars. 2019. Writer: J. White Did It;DJ White Shadow;Philip Lawrence;Bruno Mars;Cardi B.
6 Avril Lavigne

Dumb Blonde flac

Avril Lavigne. 2019. Writer: Mitch Allan;Bonnie McKee;Nicki Minaj;Avril Lavigne.
7 Alec Benjamin

Let Me Down Slowly flac

Alec Benjamin. 2019. Writer: Alec Benjamin;Sir Nolan;Michael Pollack.
8 DEAMN

Happy flac

DEAMN. 2019.
9 Ariana Grande

Needy flac

Ariana Grande. 2019. Writer: Tayla Parx;TBHits;Victoria Monét;Ariana Grande.
10 Halsey

11 Minutes flac

Halsey. 2019. Writer: Matt Schwartz;Halsey;Dominic Harrison;Brynley Plumb.
11 Lauv

I'm So Tired flac

Lauv. 2019. Writer: Lauv;Michael Pollack;Troye Sivan;Leland;OZGO.
12 Ariana Grande

Break Up With Your Girlfriend, I'm Bored flac

Ariana Grande. 2019. Writer: Kandi;Kevin "She'kspere" Briggs;Max Martin;ILYA;Savan Kotecha;Ariana Grande.
13 Bebe Rexha

Last Hurrah flac

Bebe Rexha. 2019. Writer: Andrew Wells;Nick Long;Lauren Christy;Bebe Rexha.
14 Afrojack

Ferrari flac

Afrojack. 2019.
15 Icona Pop

This Is How We Party flac

Icona Pop. 2019. Writer: R3hab;Icona Pop.
16 Armin Van Buuren

Lonely For You flac

Armin Van Buuren. 2019. Writer: Armin Van Buuren;Bonnie McKee;Eden XO;Benno De Goeij.
17 Normani

Dancing With A Stranger flac

Normani. 2019. Writer: Mikkel S. Eriksen;Tor Hermansen;Jimmy Napes;Normani;Sam Smith.
18 Julian Jordan

Need You flac

Julian Jordan. 2019.
19 Fall Out Boy

I've Been Waiting flac

Fall Out Boy. 2019. Writer: Andy Hurley;Patrick Stump;Pete Wentz;Joe Trohman;Lil Peep;​iLoveMakonnen.
20 Ariana Grande

Imagine flac

Ariana Grande. 2019. Writer: JProof;Priscilla Renea;Happy Perez;Andrew "Pop" Wansel;Ariana Grande.

Language

Categories